Spiderman 3

So, I just got back from seeing Spiderman 3. I've been a really big fan of the first two, and I maintain that #2 is one of the best comic book movies out there. #3 on the other hand, doesn't quite compare to the two of them. It tries to be both, while riding on the momentum of the series, and manages to capture some aspects of it, but mangages to create an overly complicated and somewhat jumbled mess of a film.

There are some parts that work very well. The first half of the film sets up nicely, and even sets up the various plot lines with a good degree of skill. MJ and Peter's bit of romance, Peter and Harry's problems, Sandman and the introduction of the symbiote. The movie goes on a bit and things move to a bit of a logical progression, where problems start. MJ and Peter's relationship goes haywire, and for no good reason - where it might have been resolved with a quick converstation, both characters are so bullheaded that they can't see past each other.

The main problems occur halfway through the film, mainly through things that just didn't need to be there. Peter and MJ break up, Peter turns into a hipster emo kid and is dancing through the streets. Where in Spiderman 2, the Raindrops Falling on my Head scene worked pretty well, this one was completely unneeded. Ditto for the scene in the bar when Peter suddenly plays piano and dances around there. My first throught was WTF? and desperately hoped that it was a dream sequence. Several other smaller scenes could have easily been lost and the film would have been better for it.

Other problems occured with the numerous storylines throughout the film. The Sandman story was interesting, but the director and writers killed him off not once or twice, but three times, something that never really works well in a film, especially when they keep coming back for more. The Symbiote storyline worked very well, (dancing scenes aside) as Peter got darker. Problems occured with Venom. He looked good, moved around good and sounded good, even his creation out of Eddie Brock was good, but they kept having the mask come off his face time and time again, which seemed really odd and messed up his character a lot. In addition, for all the hype that was given to the character, it wasn't around for very long. Finally, Harry's scenes could have been handled much better, as his entire stint with memory loss was both pointless and unneeded - it seemed almost as an afterthought. The theme that popped up towards the end, Choices, easily resolved Harry's need to go after Peter, and that could have been that. Finally, the last scene towards the end would have been better if they'd just gone with Venom - the gigantic sandman seemed like something out of the Hulk and ruined the pacing of the entire scene. Finally, Gwen Stacy was completely unneeded, and the casting for Eddie Brock was completely wrong, especially as Venom.

But then again, there were moments where the movie shined. Exploring Spiderman's darker side was good, especially in the light of a different killer, which was handled a lot better than I thought that it would be. Peter and MJ's scenes weren't bad save for a couple scenes. I even bought Harry's resolution to his gripes with Peter, which was handled well. Who really shined though, were Stan Lee, J.K. Simmons and Bruce Campbell. Campbell's scenes were priceless, and topped his scenes in Spiderman 2. Simmons was also very funny with his assistant reminding him of his high blood pressure, and buying the camera off of the little girl at the end. And of course, the action is spectacular, with some very, very cool scenes of jumping around, flying through the air and the hand to hand stuff.

Overall, the movie tried to capture the comic fun of the first movie, and the drama of the second. It manages to surpass the first objective, but comes up short with the second, mainly by being way too complicated than it needed to be. That aside, it's a fun addition to the Spiderman series. And, I think that I wouldn't mind seeing another Spiderman movie with the current cast again.

D-Day 4 – 9: Days 5 to 10

On the 9th of June, the 101st Airborne, with the 506th, 502nd and 501st regiments, and presumably, Private Austin, attacked the German-held town of Carentan. The 501st attacked from the Northwest, where they captured a hill. Over the next several days, the 101st airborne would work to hold the town and defend key routes into the city.[1] Elements of the 175th Infantry would also participate in Carentan, but is it not likely that Lieutenant Jerome Eastman, NU ’32, would have participated. As he had been wounded several days earlier, when he first reached Normandy.[2] The capture of Carentan would link the two American beaches into a continuous front.

June 7th through the 11th showed the arrival of one of the most important units to the battle, the 2nd Armored Division, and along with it, Captain Gordon Fuller, NU ‘38, General Edward Brooks, NU ‘16, Colonel I.D. White, NU ‘22, Captain Sten Bergstedt, NU ’32, Lieutenant Col Briard Johnson, NU ’27 (and later, Commandant and Professor of Military Sciences), and Captain James Burt, NU ‘39. They arrived on Omaha Beach. In addition, the 39th Infantry, with Norwich alumni Colonel Harry ‘Paddy’ Flint, NU ’10, and Lieutenant Arnold MacKerer, NU ‘46, arrived on Utah Beach.

The Second Armored division, under the command of General Brooks, embarked for Normandy on the 6th of June, and arrived on the 7th, where they appear to have landed in several stages. General Brooks arrived on the 7th. While landing, a landing craft exploded next to Brook’s ship; close enough to push it around.[3] It is likely that Captain Gordon Fuller, NU ’38, was aboard this LST, as Colonel White, NU ’22, noted in an interview years later that the LST belonged to the 67th Regiment, which Captain Fuller was assigned to[4]. He would prove to be the first Norwich casualty in the Normandy Invasion, before he even reached the beachhead.

Command Combat B, which was commanded by Col. I.D. White (‘22), arrived June 8th, where they spent the rest of the day de-waterproofing their equipment and by that night, the entire unit moved to the Tournieres and Littry area, where they prepared for combat and scouted the area for enemy emplacements and for safe routes in the region[5]. Once the 2nd Armored division had landed in Normandy, the initial phase of the invasion was completed.[6] The next phase was to secure the Normandy region. The 2nd Armored Division was called into action to help reinforce the forces already in the battlefield, as there were reports that the Germans were launching a counter attack. On the 12th of June, the division began to carry out attacks on the Germans, first reinforcing a group of soldiers from the 101st Airborne division near Carentan. The 66th Regiment, which Captain Sten Bergstedt, NU ’32, was attached to, would remain with the 101st Airborne division and the 83rd Infantry division, until early July.[7] While this was happening, Combat Command B, under Colonel I.D. White, was clearing the assembly area of mines and the unit worked to find ways to fight in the Normandy hedgerows, as well as the use of armored and infantry units in support of each other.

The 39th Infantry Division, commanded by Colonel Harry Flint, NU ’10, also landed on the 11th of June, at Utah Beach. Lieutenant Arnold MacKerer Jr., NU ’46, was also a member of this unit, assigned to E-Company. The unit landed in the morning and marched to St. Mere Eglise and was immediately sent to Quinneville with Patton’s 4th Division. They arrived on June 14th and engaged the German defenders in the area there. Initially, they met heavy enemy fire and were forced to withdraw, but within the day, the Division was able to break the German lines at Quinneville. The unit was able to rest for a couple days, but was back on the line by the 16th, where they worked to cut off the peninsula that was one of the larger goals of the American forces in the area, something that was achieved by the 18th of June, granting the Allied forces a large port. The next week would be spent neutralizing the enemy forces that had been cornered by the attack.



[1] Ibid, 359-360

[2] Ibid

[3] Huston, 199

[4] Strodter, 224

[5] CCB Periodic Report, 7-11 June

[6] Huston, 200

[7] Huston, 203

D+ 1-3: Days 2-4

The subsequent days after the initial invasion brought in a number of new units to reinforce the soldiers who had arrived earlier. The only Norwich alumnus to arrive on June 7th was Jerome Eastman, NU ’32, of the 747th Tank Battalion. He arrived in France through Omaha beach and was attached to the 175th Infantry of the 29th Division.[1] They landed at 1230, later than expected, and seem to be the first real reinforcements that the forces at Omaha received.[2] The 175th went into action near the town of Gruchy, and it is assumed that the 747th was with them there as well.[3] During the invasion, Eastman was wounded and awarded the Silver Star for his actions in Normandy.[4] It is assumed that he was pulled from the front line, and would return later.

Other units were also in action on the 7th of June. Private Austin with the 501st may have been located with the rest of his unit near Douve, where they were running short of ammunition, although they were able to hold off a battalion of German paratroopers from advancing on St. Marie-du-mont.[5] Lieutenant Eugenio Bonafin (‘43) with the 87th Chemical Mortars was still linked with the 8th Infantry for one more day, before being reassigned to the 12th Infantry on the 8th of June. They advanced on Ste. Mere Eglise on the 7th, and moved towards Montebourg on the 8th.[6] McNamara and Raymond with the 1st Division would have spend much of the 7th fighting around Colleville[7], with the assumption that they were able to find their unit, as it appears that they had been in a different area the day before. In the day after D-Day, the units would have been working more closely together, as they would have had the time and space to regroup.

Major Jim Ballard, NU ’39, and Lieutenant George Briggs, NU ‘32, with the 116th Infantry Regiment, were sent to Pointe Du Hoe, where the US Army Rangers had landed the day before. They made quick progress out to them, and were able to free the Rangers, who had been under heavy fire throughout the night.[8]

On June 8th, the 357th Infantry Regiment, landed at Utah Beach. It is possible that Private Henry Ball, NU ’36, landed with them on this day. The regiment arrived on short around noon, and by the next day, went into action, helping to expand the beachfront. [9]

No Norwich alumni seem to have landed in Normandy on the 9th of June, but on the 10th, Major Henry Osthues, NU ’40, of the 413th AAA Gun Battalion arrived as part of the 9th Infantry Division through Utah Beach. They seem to have had a couple of days to organize, and by the 14th of June, the 9th Division was placed in charge of the attack on Cherbourg.[10] The exact nature of Major Osthues’s role in the battle is not known.



[1] Ibid, 352

[2] Ibid, 337

[3] Ibid, 345

[4] 1947 War Whoop (Need Page)

[5] Harrison, 347

[6] Elliot, 17

[7] Ambrose, Stephen, Citizen Soldiers, Simon & Schuster, New York, New York, 38

[8] Harrison, 341

[9] Roeder, George Von, Regimental History of the 357th Regiment. http://www.90thdivisionassoc.org/90thDivisionFolders/357thbook/357thhistory.htm

[10] Harrison, 403

Geeking Out

Okay, this just made my day: BookBD. It's a book database system, freeware, that's very, very simple to use. It's, for all intents and purposes, an electronic card catalog, that tracks book titles, authors, publishers, prices, editions, page numbers, and on and on. Enough to keep me very occupied and geeking out, because I really dig this stuff. I've been doing it on my own for years, on Excell, but this is much, much better. Weee!

Day 1: D-Day

The invasion of Normandy was undertaken by the American, British and Canadian militaries on five separate beaches in Normandy France. The British forces landed at Gold and Sword, the Canadian forces landed at Juno, and the American army landed on Omaha and Utah, with Airborne forces being dropped behind Utah overnight.

The Norwich University alumni who were in the ground invasion were Major Bill
McNamara, NU '36, Lieutenant Thurber Raymond, NU ’41, and Lt. Colonel Carroll Stowell, NU '40, of the 1st Infantry, Major Jim Ballard, NU '39, and Lieutenant George Briggs, NU '32, of the 29th Infantry, Captain Arthur Harrington, NU ’40, of the 5th Special Engineer Brigade, Lieutenant Eugenio Bonafin, NU '43, of the 87th Chemical Mortar Battalion, Lieutenant Thomas Fulham, NU ’47, and Lieutenant Robert Harrington, NU ’47, of the 4th Infantry Division, Lieutenant Lawrence Elman, NU '43 and Lieutenant Fredrick Meinken, NU '47, of the 4th Cavalry Regiment and Private Richard Austin, NU '44 of the 101st Airborne. In the air, Lieutenant David Steward, NU '47, Captain Jim McCarthy, NU ‘40, Lieutenant Sherman Crocker, NU ‘44, and Sergeant William Crawthorne, NU ’47, and possibly Sergeant Edward T. Yeller, NU ‘49, of the 9th Air Force were also involved with the invasion, covering the ground forces with bombardment runs in Thunderbolt fighters or bombers. In addition, Lieutenant Edwyn Florcyk, NU ‘44, of the 8th Air Force, was also present in the airs above Normandy. It is also possible that Sergeant Mitchell Esoian, NU ‘49, Sergeant George Edwin Guidi, NU ‘49 and Sergeant Robert Wieler, NU ‘49, all part of the 8th Air Force also participated in various bombing or escort missions during the lead up to D-Day or during the actual invasion.

Prior to the beach landings, elements of the 8th and 9th Air Force Bombers began to bomb German emplacements, in order to hamper the enemy’s ability to repel the incoming American soldiers. However, due to the poor weather and overcast skies, pilots were forced to rely on instruments, or release their payloads late, causing most of the bombs to land in the wrong places.[1] In addition to the aerial bombardments, allied ships just off the coast of Normandy began their own bombardment of the landing sites, to further disrupt the German force’s ability to counter attack. These would be slightly more effective, as they would later be credited to opening up key areas for infantry to enter.[2] Captain McCarthy described some of what he saw on June 6th to reporters, an account that was later picked up by the Norwich University Record for the July, 1944 edition:

One minute, the houses of Caen were sitting side by side and the next minute, there weren’t any houses in the center of town at all. There was nothing but flames, rubble and dust…. We dropped down through the overcast on inspection. All of a sudden Caen just went completely to pieces in the center. Sidewalks, trees, houses, parked vehicles seemed to melt away.[3]

Captain McCarthy had witnessed the navel bombardment from off the coast of Normandy, targeting German emplacements inland.

Private Richard Austin, NU ’44, would have been the first of the Norwich alumni to land in Normandy, just after midnight on June the 6th. Over 13,000 airborne soldiers were dropped over the Normandy region during the early hours of the 6th, taking the German forces in the area completely by surprise.[4] The airborne mission was to secure vital areas behind the beaches that would soon be visited by American soldiers. While the German forces were surprised, they did react to the airborne invasion, throwing up flak that would scatter the planes, and along with less than favorable weather conditions, turn the airborne landings into a mess of soldiers. Most would not land in the right place. It is unknown where Private Austin landed on the morning of the 6th, although much of the 101st Airborne division landed somewhere behind Utah Beach. Austin survived the jump into Normandy, and it is possible that he would have found some of his fellow members of the 501st Regiment and, most likely, other members of the 101st and 82nd airborne divisions. Many objectives were undertaken by soldiers from different units, improvising to their surroundings and nearby targets. By the end of the day on June 6th, only 2,500 of the 6,600 troopers were organized into their units. While very disorganized, they were instrumental in beginning to secure the area for the soldiers coming in from the beaches.[5]

In front of the airborne landings was Utah Beach. The Norwich alumni who landed there was Lieutenant Eugenio Bonafin of the 87th Chemical Mortar Battalion, Lieutenant Lawrence Elman, NU ’42, Lieutenant Fredrick Meinken, NU '47, with the 4th Cavalry Regiment, Lieutenant Thomas Fulham, NU ’47, and Lieutenant Robert Harrington, NU ’47, of the 4th Infantry Division.

The 4th Cavalry Regiment put the first sea-borne soldiers into Normandy, two hours before H-Hour (0430) to take out a suspected observation post. Off shore to the North from Utah Beach are the St. Marcouf Islands; reconnaissance planes had spotted buildings that could pose a problem for the upcoming landings. The unit, along with the 24th Cavalry, found that the islands were abandoned, but was cluttered with mines, which killed and wounded a number of soldiers who had landed.[6] Neither Lieutenant Lawrence Elman, NU ‘42, nor Lieutenant Fredrick Meinken, NU '47, was among the casualties on the island.

The 4th Infantry Division was one of the first divisions to land on Utah Beach, and was able to do so with little difficulty – they received only scattered gunfire. Because of the weather, the entire landing was pushed down the beach, into a quieter region. While this meant that there was little resistance, the invading army had only one exit, a single causeway, rather than two at the original landing site. From the beaches, the US forces would move inwards, and link up with the 101st and 82nd Airborne Divisions, who had landed the night before, and had been tasked with securing the key roads in the area. The exact role that Lieutenant Thomas Fulham, NU ’47, and Lieutenant Robert Harrington, NU ’47, played in the invasion is unknown, although it is likely that they were involved with the invasion, given their unit. Harrington (No relation to Captain Arthur Harrington, who was landing at Omaha on the same day) was a member of the 4th Recon Troop, which might have been an early arrival to the beach. Fulham was a member of the 22nd Infantry Regiment, and would have most likely landed with the bulk of the attacking force.

In the 87th Mortar Battalion, Lieutenant Bonafin, NU ’43, would have landed alongside various infantry units as they landed on Utah. He was assigned to A Company, in support of 1st Battalion of the 8th Infantry Division. The mortar battalion landed later in the attack, after the first waves of infantry hit the beaches. With the first waves, forward observers had landed from his unit, and by the time Lieutenant Bonafin would have landed, they would have called in information once the unit had deployed their mortars. The mortar battalions launched a number of rounds that morning in support of infantry, and after about an hour, moved inland, keeping pace with the advancing infantry. During the attack, they targeted a number of enemy emplacements, such as machine gun posts and pillboxes. His unit would continue to support the 8th Infantry in the days ahead.[7]

The initial landings at Utah Beach went along fairly smoothly. There was almost no opposition during H-Hour (0630), but the entire first waves of soldiers arrived at the beaches in the wrong locations, almost two thousand yards from where they were supposed to land. While the units landed on in an area that was lightly defended, all of their planned actions were useless, and units were forced to improvise.

Omaha Beach was another story entirely. Landing teams faced heavy opposition on the beaches, with entire platoons being killed before they even reached the sand and a number of the landing craft ended up in the wrong place due to poor weather. The Norwich Alumni who landed on Omaha were Major Bill McNamara, NU ‘36, Lieutenant Thurber Raymond ‘41, Lt. Colonel Carroll Stowell, NU ‘40, Major Jim Ballard, NU ’39, Lieutenant George Briggs, NU ’32 and Captain Arthur Harrington, NU ‘40. Major McNamara and Lieutenant Raymond were both part of the 1st Infantry, 1st Regiment, and were some of the first soldiers to land on the beaches, although their exact landing sites are unknown. Lt. Colonel Stowell was also part of the 1st Infantry, but was a member of the 1st Engineer Combat Battalion. Major Ballard and Lieutenant Briggs were both members of the 29th Infantry. Major McNamara’s boat dropped his platoon in the wrong location, due to rough seas and upon landing, came under fire from German machine guns. While he was unharmed, the next boat down the line was hit, cutting down most of the soldiers inside. After the landing, he and his soldiers moved up the beach, seeking shelter in a trench. They were on the beach for about an hour, before moving on.[8] Major McNamara would later be awarded an oak leaf cluster for the Silver Star for his actions on June 6th, as his unit came under fire, he moved up the beach and was able to locate a trench, which he led his unit to, possibly saving many lives.[9]

Major Jim Ballard, NU ‘39, and Lieutenant George Briggs, NU ’32, of the 116th Infantry, attached to the 29th Infantry, would have also likely been among the first waves of the assault on Omaha Beach. It is not known exactly what squads they was attached to, but it is likely that he would have landed on the Easy Green, Dog Red, Dog White or Dog Green sectors, within the first 50 minutes of the attack.[10] Lieutenant Briggs led a platoon of riflemen during the invasion.

Captain Arthur Harrington, NU ’40, landed in-between the 1st and 29th Divisions, and was attached to the 5th Engineer Special Brigade, and was tasked with linking communications between both divisions to better coordinate their attacks on the beach. He landed at H + 6 on Easy One, a beach sector on Omaha, several hours after the initial waves, but still received enemy fire, the only time during the war.

In most cases, the mission of the first waves of soldiers was to do either one of two things: attack the German emplacements to secure the beach for the next wave, or to clear the beach of emplacements, booby traps and barriers, as the latter waves of tanks and heavy artillery would be slowed by the German defenses. They were to breach the German defenses in two hours, and work their way inland. However , a number of problems occurred as a result of mis-landings and heavy enemy fire, destroying the engineering equipment or detonating explosives. In addition, few of the landing craft made it to the shores before beaching, requiring most of the soldiers to wade into the beaches, making them easy targets for Germans soldiers.[11]

By 0800 to 0900, breakthroughs to the bluffs overlooking the beaches were being made, although soldiers did so without the support of much artillery or armor. For the rest of the day, much of the fighting behind Omaha was in three areas: Colleville, St. Laurent and Vierville-sur-Mer. In all areas, units were met with German resistance. It seems, given the citation for Major McNamara’s actions on June 6th, that his unit was in the Vierville-sur-Mer area.[12] This also seems to be where much of the 116th Infantry and Rangers were concentrated, and it is likely that Major Ballard and Lieutenant Briggs were also be in this area after leaving the beach. In the first day, they had only established a foothold that extended roughly a mile and a half into France.[13] At the same time, the units coming in from Utah beach met with far less resistance.[14] By the end of the day, casualties at Utah Beach numbered only around two hundred[15], while the casualties at Omaha beach were nearly ten times that, with around two thousand killed.[16]



[1] Harrison, 300

[2] Harrison, 302

[3] Norwich Record, July 1944

[4] Harrison, 278-279

[5] Harrison, 288

[6] Ryan, Cornelius. The Longest Day: The Classic Epic of D-Day. Simon & Schuster, New York, New York, 162

[7] Elliot, Bruce. Unit History of the 87th Chemical Mortar Battalion, http://www.4point2.org/hist-87.htm#0644. (2006)

[8] Sivret, 1

[9] September 1, 1944 Norwich University Record, 26

[10] US War Department Historical Division, Omaha Beachhead, Washington D.C., 31

[11] Ibid, 42-44

[12] September 1, 1944 Norwich University Record, 26

[13] Harrison, 329

[14] Ibid, 328

[15] Ibid, 329

[16] Ibid, 330

Part One: Pre-Normandy – The War, Invasion Planning and Preparation


By June of 1944, the war in Europe had been raging for almost five years. German forces had occupied much of mainland Europe, North Africa and were preparing to invade Russia. Prior to the United State’s entrance to the war, Great Britain was the only country to rebuff the Germans, mainly due to the location and nature of the British Isles. In December of 1941, Japanese forces successfully attacked US military sites in the Pacific basin, bringing the US to a state of war with Japan, and soon, Germany. Despite Japan’s aggression, the United States made the defeat of Germany a priority, as the German military was deemed as more of a threat to US interests.[1]

Right after the attack, the US and British governments began to work collectively on a plan to defeat Germany. By June 1942, the United States proposed a plan to invade France via the English Channel and begin fighting on the mainland, before the year was out, with the aim to reach Germany by the following year. The British were in favor of this plan, taking to heart memories of World War I, where months of trench warfare proved to be devastating. Across the war zone, the Russians were pushing for an attack on the western front of the war, to relieve pressure off of their own country, as the German military was firmly entrenched in the western sections of Russia. However, American and British military officials would postpone their invasion plans in favor of an attack on North Africa.[2]

In November of 1942, allied forces attacked Morocco and Algeria, catching the occupying Vichi-French forces by surprise. In response, the Germans moved quickly down and occupied French Tunisia, beginning several months of desert warfare before the allied forces were able to surround and capture the remaining German forces in May 1943. The US actions in Northern Africa would become a proving ground for a number of units on the ground – some of the units associated with Norwich alumni, such as the Second Armored Division and the 39th Infantry had fought in Africa, before being moved to England in preparation for the coming invasion. [3]

During this time, Norwich University remained in session until an early commencement in March of 1943, when almost all of the 500 Norwich Cadets departed for military service. Following the exodus of students, the Army Air Corps moved in and used the school as a pre-flight training facility for future pilots and bombers. The Junior Cadet Corps was also set up during this time, which would use an accelerated learning program for pre-high school graduates with the aim to prepare them for military service. The program was discontinued in 1946 after much criticism.[4] The school would resume traditional services after the war ended in 1945.[5]

Following victory in Africa, the allies moved onwards towards Italy, taking Sicily in August of 1943. However, political troubles and a renewed German defense would prevent allies from taking Rome until June 1944. The allies split their attention between Italy and preparations for the upcoming invasion of France. American and British bombers flew over Axis territory from early 1943 onwards, working to disrupt as much of the German infrastructure as possible. Allied forces took heavy losses and were unable to disrupt the Germans as much as had been hoped. They were, however, able to gain air supremacy, and were thus able to focus on the Normandy region.[6]

In the early months of 1944, planning for the cross-channel invasion was well underway, having been started in March of 1943. However, it became clear that any invasion in 1943 would be unreasonable and the invasion was planned for 1944.[7] Numerous units were relocated to England, where they received months of training and preparation for the impending assault. In the months leading up to the invasion, millions of soldiers, as well as their supplies, arrived in England. Field units, such as the Second Armored division, found the move to England to be very favorable. They were set up in proper barracks with beds. Unfortunately, the wet environment led to many soldiers getting ill with respiratory infections. It was also during this time that they were issued new equipment for their training and preparations for the invasion.[8] General I.D. White, NU ’22, recalled that the sheer number of soldiers in the area made field training problematic:

We had rather limited maneuver facilities in England. There was a range, Imber Range, where we could fire very limited ranges with our tank weapons and artillery, as there were few places that were not under cultivation. There was very little room even for tank driving courses in the Salisbury Plain area, really. There were so many units there, US and British units that they were just overcrowded with what room there was.[9]

During this time, in the months leading up to the invasion, the operation was meticulously planned out, under the watch of General Dwight Eisenhower. The overall plan was split the invasion into three parts. The first was the invasion itself, and the immediate establishment of a foothold. The second was a buildup of allied forces and a breakout into the Brittany-Normandy region. Once those two objectives were completed, the allies would push the German forces back on a large scale.[10]

In addition to training, the men in the units were preparing mentally for what they were likely to accomplish. While they did not know specific details about the invasion, such as the timing or exact location; they did know that they were to invade the continent, and in all likelihood, it would be a very costly endeavor. Col. Harry Flint, NU ‘10, commanding officer of the 39th Infantry division, was preparing his men for such an assault as early as April 1944:

Let’s face a few facts flatly. We know that soon the greatest and most powerful force of all history will make an invasion of the west coast of Europe. We know that we will be a part of that first force which lands. We know that the whole operation has been carefully planned…. We know there will be casualties – that can’t be helped. It is certain that if each one will play his part and not fail a comrade then our casualties will be the smaller. [11]

In addition to preparation and planning, the American soldiers were tightly clustered together in the southern regions of England. A number of men would take their leaves and travel to London or any number of the larger English cities and would report back to the Norwich University Record. Norwich alumni often sought each other out or found each other during this time of preparation. The institutional bonds these men formed brought them together, far from home, facing one of the most terrifying things that they would most likely come against. Captain Arthur Harrington, NU ’40, recalled meeting Col. Homer Riggs, NU ’26, in England prior to the invasion, and because of their shared Norwich background, they became friends, with Riggs constantly pushing Harrington for recognition. Others would share similar stories, often meeting in London, or other cities, while on leave.

Training for the invasion covered many aspects of what was expected once the Germans were engaged in Normandy. While it was assumed that a number of units would be ready for action based on their training, British and American planners devised tactics tailored for an England to France invasion. Training centers were established, and units visited to brush up on tactics. Four Norwich alumni, Lieutenant George Briggs, NU ‘32, and Jim Ballard, NU ’39, would have gone through training at the Assault Training Center during their assignment with the 116th Infantry for a refresher course, while Lieutenant Thomas Fulham, NU ‘47, and Lieutenant Robert Harrington, NU ’47 would have also participated with the 4th Infantry Division. Other units would have skipped the training, having already participated in battles against German or Italian forces.[12] Other units were also working to fix problems or concerns that were noted during previous engagements. Members of the 2nd Armored Division, represented by Captain James Burt, NU ‘39, Captain Sten Bergstedt, NU ’32, and Captain Gordon Fuller, NU ’38, would have also received new trainings and briefings in the technical aspects of water landings, mines and other possible hazards.[13] Bergstedt would have also received a very different method of training – in order to better practice field movement, the members of the 66th Regiment chased rabbits (which were found to mimic all the movements of tanks) while training in England.[14]

During the months leading up to the invasion, starting in December of 1943, the Ninth Air Force was brought to England and strengthened. By the time that the invasion was underway, the group had flown over thirty thousand missions against German targets, mainly against flying bomb installations deemed a threat to London and the massing of American soldiers being brought to the country for the upcoming invasion.[15] Captain Jim McCarthy, NU ’40, Lieutenant Sherman Crocker, NU ‘44, Sergeant William Crawthrorne, NU ’47, and Lieutenant David Stewart, NU ’47, were part of the 9th Air Force in fighter squadrons, and would most likely have flown on these missions, in support of the heavy bombers that were also part of the unit. Lieutenant Edwyn Florcyk, NU ’44, was assigned to the 8th Air Force, which had been linked to the 9th for the missions over Europe during this time. In addition, Sergeant Mitchell Esoian, NU ‘49, Sergeant George Edwin Guidi, NU ’49, and Sergeant Robert Wheeler, NU ’49, were members of the 8th Air Force and Sergeant Edward T. Yeller, NU ‘49, was part of the 9th Air Force, and it is probably that they would have also been involved in the bombings prior to the invasion as well. However, the German V-Bomb attac ks were not deemed as much of a threat, and once this was established, the primary target for the Ninth Air Force became the German Air Force; once that was largely eliminated, destruction of the French rail system, with concentrated bombing in routes leading to the Normandy area, to cripple the German’s ability to re-supply and regroup during the invasion. Along with the Eighth Air Force, targets also included industrial sites to slow Germany’s military efforts further.[16] These bombings were carried out into the weeks leading up to D-Day.

In May, the invasion was set for June 5th. Soldiers were moved towards the southern end of England, where the major ports were located, and where final training and preparation for the invasion was made. Units were moved towards the embarkation areas roughly in the order in which they would be landing. An excerpt from Command Combat B, of the Second Armored Division, under the command of General Edward Brooks (’16), details the unit’s movements just prior to the invasion:

1-6 June

Units of Command Combat “B” on alert, prepared for movement to marshalling area for overseas embarkation. Co. “B” 17th Engrs Bn moved to Marshalling Area

7-11 June

On 7 June HQ CC “B” and some units began movement from Tidworth barracks, England, to marshalling area.[17]

The final weeks leading up to the invasion seem to have offered insufficient training for the assault troops. Two exercises were conducted, Tiger and Fabius, to prepare the soldiers for the landings. The American soldiers spent the rest of the month waiting for orders. These would come in the last week of May. Most of the Norwich alumni involved with the landings would have been briefed during this time on the details of the invasion. Then Colonel I.D. White, NU ’22, had been briefed earlier, given his relatively high rank. To gain access to the briefing, he was required to have a security card. While he was entering the briefing, General Bradley appeared, but did not have his card. The guard at the door would not allow him access, so White vouched for him, and they were both given access to the briefing.[18]

The invasion’s final date had been set for June 5th. However, the English Channel was covered in low clouds and high winds, which would hamper the bombardment of the coast by ships and planes. Forecasters believed that the weather would improve the following day, enough to allow for better bombing and landing conditions. However, should the 6th not work, the invasion would have to wait another two weeks for the same lighting and tidal conditions. The two-week wait would also mean that the airborne forces would have to operate without moonlight.[19]

Colonel Harry Flint, NU ’10, and his soldiers from the 39th Infantry, received their orders on May 27th, and on June 3rd, the unit was driven twenty miles to their marshalling area, where they would soon board their ships on the 6th of June.[20]

Other soldiers, such as Major Bill McNamara, NU ’36, Lt. Colonel Carroll Stowell, NU ‘40 and Lieutenant Thurber Raymond, NU ’41, of the 1st Infantry Division, Major Jim Ballard, NU ’39, and Lieutenant George Briggs, NU ‘32 of the 29th Infantry, Lieutenant Eugenio Bonafin, NU ’43, of the 87th Chemical Mortar battalion, and Lieutenant Lawrence Elman, NU ’42, and possibly Lieutenant Fredrick Meinken, NU '47, of the 4th Calvary boarded their ships earlier, and on the evening of June 5th, they made their final preparations to land on the beaches of Normandy. Private Richard Austin, NU‘44, of the 101st Airborne, would have made his final preparations throughout the rest of the afternoon and before midnight on the 5th, would have been flying over the channel towards Normandy, France.



[1] Tindall, George, America: A Narrative History, W.W. Norton & Company, New York, New York1204-1205

[2] Tindall, 1205-1206

[3] Houston, Donald. Hell on Wheels: The 2nd Armored Division. Presidio Press, San Rafael, California 186

[4] Guinn, Robert. The History Of Norwich University, Volume 4. Norwich University, Northfield, Vermont. 115-116

[5] Ibid, 116

[6] Tindall, 1212

[7] Harrison, Gordon. The European Theater of Operations: Cross Channel Attack. Center of Military History, United States Army, Washington D.C., 49

[8] Stodter, Col. Charles. Project 78-D, Isaac D. White, Retired. 210-211

[9] Ibid, 215

[10] Houston, 197

[11] Anderson, Robert. The Colorful Story of Colonel Harry A. 'Paddy' Flint. Heritage Books, Westminster, Maryland, 114

[12] Harrison, 162-164

[13] Houston, 191

[14] Ibid

[15] Houston, 214-215

[16] Houston, 224

[17] Lt. Col Briard Johnson Papers, Box 1, Operations Repots, 1942 – 1945, Archives and Special Collections, Kreitzberg Library, Norwich University, Northfield, Vermont.

[18] Stodter, 222

[19] Harrison, 272-273

[20] Anderson, 119

Norwich University Alumni and the Invasion of Normandy : Introduction

As promised, I'm going to split up my paper and post it up, section by section over the next week. It's been turned in, along with the map and final appendixes, and I guess now, all that I have to do is wait for my grades. Two exams to write up and a power point, and I'll be completely done with college.

This paper is not to be reprinted anywhere else. It's my own research and feel free to link to this blog, or link and post an excerpt, but no copy and paste jobs please.

Introduction

“Your task will not be an easy one. Your enemy is well trained, well equipped, and battle-hardened. He will fight savagely.”

- General Dwight D. Eisenhower



On June 6th, 1944, the combined forces of the United States of America, the United Kingdom and Canada launched one of the largest amphibious invasions that the world has ever seen to begin the massive task of retaking the European continent from the control of the German military. Over two million soldiers participated in the Allied invasion and aftermath, creating a vital foothold in Europe that would begin the end of the Second World War.

While the number of soldiers that were involved in the invasion numbered in the millions, thirty of Norwich University alumni were among them, representing all levels of the military, from privates to generals, on each of the American invasion beaches and landing sites and from the first moments of the battle through the days after the initial invasion. These soldiers from Norwich University were also represented in a number of different units, ranging from armored divisions to medical units and would have thus been involved in all aspects of the invasion. An examination of the Norwich alumni present during the Invasion of Normandy proves to be a microcosm for the entire invasion – a fairly complete view of the battle can be seen through the actions of the Norwich men who were involved with the invasion.

Up until now, there has been very little research into the role of Norwich University in one of the most notable moments in world and military history. For the 50th anniversary of D-Day, in 1994, a local paper, the Times Argus, interviewed Norwich alumni William McNamara, who participated in the opening moments of the invasion, to commemorate the occasion, while the Norwich University Record reprinted an article regarding the invasion, from its archives in June of 1944. More recently, a list of thirteen men who fought in the battle, only to perish later in the war, was generated from various sources was created to commemorate the 60th anniversary of the invasion. This list, however, did not take into account the numerous other soldiers who fought in the invasion, and survived, and in addition, includes several errors regarding battlefield details.

To better understand the role that Norwich University men played in the invasion, a more detailed study and examination of sources was conducted. The Norwich University Record, War Whoop and deceased constituents files were examined, and a list of 121 names was generated, from which, a more accurate list of D-Day invasion veterans, numbering thirty-seven who were either confirmed to have been involved in the invasion, or had a high probability of participating. Each of these sources contained information confirming that there were more than thirteen Norwich alumni present at the battle and that a number of the D-Day veterans survived the invasion and actions afterwards. Careful study of the unit actions offers a better understanding of the role of Norwich men in the invasion. The results of this study show that Norwich University alumni played a significant role in some aspects of the invasion and securing of Normandy, but collectively, they represented every aspect of war fighting.

Done!

As of 11:27 this morning, my Normandy paper is done. Finished. End of story, for me anyway. Rounding out at 46 pages, including the bibliography, order of battle appendix, list of soldiers appendix and the full body of the paper, I have three copies, neatly stapled, sitting in a folder in front of me, looking nice, crisp and ready to turn in to my professor, President Schneider and Captain Arthur Harrington, whom I interviewed. The very last thing that I'm waiting for is a map that will be printed out in the next fifteen or so minutes that shows the Normandy coastline, the beaches and the relative locations and landing times of each of the soldiers that I researched.

But... it's over. It's kind of hard to believe that, when I was sitting in class, wracked with a cold, raising my hand to take the D-Day project when it was first announced. Then came the hours in the library, searching for references, then up to Jackman hall to look at old records, Archives and Special Collections and finding more things, beginning to type up things, making connections between people and places, cross-referencing sources, beginning the writing, scanning pictures, putting together a powerpoint (which I need to revise for a presentation in two weeks), going over the paper with Professor Lord, and now, it's sitting here, a finished product, as good as I can make it (And there's probably some more that can be done to it, including research on a couple of people who I just added in at the last minute), but that's it for me.

If people are interested, I've been thinking of serializing the paper, section by section up here, if people are interested. Because dammit, if I put all this work into it, I get to be a little vain and want to show it off a bit.

I liked doing this paper. I loved the research, finding things and putting together all the pieces into this larger picture. That's what I want to do with my life. I got such a rush being able to put together something new, something that has never been researched like this, and I'm realising that there's a whole lot more that I could do with this project. I could expand it to further battles beyond D-Day for Norwich alumni, such as St. Lo, the Battle of the Bulge, Operation Market-Garden, the Invasion of North Africa and Italy, and the list goes on and on. Who knows, maybe I'll get to do something more like this.

Revisions, Projects and Deadlines

It's one week to go before classes are finally over, and exactly one week before my Normandy paper is due to class. The amount of work that I've done on it since receiving the edits? Minimal. I didn't even start my english paper until about 12 hours before it was due, although that came together really quickly. My work ethic is sucking this week, I think senioritis kicked in becauseohgodintwoweeksi'mgoingtograduateandi'llbedonewithschoolfortheforseeablefuture. Gah. Part of me is very happy about this. The part isn't, because I genuinely enjoy learning and this sort of thing. I'm still thinking and planning on attending graduate school at some point, with the intention to teach or research history somewhere, because this is what I like doing. In the meantime, I have to actually find a job and you know, a place to live.I'm currently editing a paper for another member of my NU History Seminar, on the US Militia System and our school's founder, Alden Partridge. It's an interesting read, and we're hearing three more presentations later today. I need to type up a critique for this paper, and I think I've found some good things to discuss. After being rejected from Abnaki this year, I've started concentrating on full time jobs for the time being. I've applied to another book store with the intent on working there and Walden Books and getting some hours between them, which would be nice. I like Bear Pond Books, and have shopped there all my life. It's one of the independant bookstores in Montpelier, and has a very cool atmosphere to it. I've also gotten a called from the Green Mountain Club for an interview with them, which would be very, very cool. My outlook on the summer has improved dramatically. I've also learned that a new airline is about to start operating, something similar to Ryanair (a UK carrier), that has prices that are literally as low as they can get. On a good day, a round trip flight to Ohio will cost me under $40. Hopefully, this will help me and Sarah get together more often, as it's quite expensive and time consuming to drive from here to there. Also, Drive was cancelled yesterday. Once again, Fox torched a show because of lackluster ratings, although this one was probably cancelled for more reason than Firefly was. (Tim Minear was a producer for Firefly, and the creator of Drive). Poor Nathan Fillion can't get a break with his shows. Drive did have potential, but nowhere near Firefly's. It had an interesting premise, some interesting characters, but a very limited premise - While it would have been an interesting thing to see play out, but some of the characters were really irritating. Fox was behind this show, unlike with Firefly. There was a ton of ads for it, and really early ads for it - Fox wanted this to work - unfortunently, the viewers just weren't there - The show got about a 2.5/6 rating for the first episodes and was dragging 24, one of Fox's most popular shows, down. It's a pity, this year there were a bunch of cool shows that were cancelled. Andy Barker PI, Smith, Drive, Studio 60 (most likely), Black Donnellys, Daybreak, The Nine, among others. Hopefully, there'll be some of the good shows, such as Heroes, Raines, LOST, Supernatural and Veronica Mars, that will get another couple of seasons. Right, back to my editing...

Toy Soldiers Hope For Better Years

So, I turned in my paper last week, the last draft, for review, and had my first presentation in front of the class on the topic. It went over well, aside from the fact that I went over my time by 20 minutes. People seemed to like it, a couple of my classmates told me that it was very interesting, and hopefully, I got good marks from them on my presentation.
Earlier today, I had a meeting with my professor on my draft - he's been spending the last couple of days working them all over (Fortunently, there's only eight of us) and he gave mine back, covered in red ink. It wasn't as bad as I thought that it might be, mostly mechanical stuff and citations, which I really need to redo. But he liked the paper, thought that I did good research, and I have two weeks to finish working that up. I'm going through it now, getting all the easier things to correct. So, it's going along a lot easier than I thought that it would.

Now that a bulk of the work is done, I can resume normal school work, stuff that I've kind of pushed aside for a while - back math homework and an english paper that I have to get done. I'd rather just avoid it.

Picked up a couple of books, the first called Miles from Nowhere, from the Northfield Bookstore, and J.R.R. Tolkien's latest, Children of Hurin, which is really good, but I need to really concentrate reading it, because otherwise, I end up missing tons of things. That was a complete impulse buy, last night at work, mainly because it was 40% off, more than my employee discount, and mainly because it's so shiny.

I also helped out at school with Jr. Ring, which in my four years at Norwich, I've never actually been to, (Celebration 3, London and the girl being out of state all reasons why I've never bothered to go), setting up the stage for the band that came in, and tearing it down again after the show. Band was Armor For Sleep, some emo-rock group that wasn't that good. They did sound a whole lot less whiny in person, but they're nobody that I'd ever recommend to anyone. I only caught the last twenty or so minutes of their set. The stage was more interesting.

Now, I'm going to procrastinate further by watching Long Way Round or reading Hurin. Hm...

Living History

My presentation for my Norwich D-Day Project is today. In 30 minutes, to be precise, and I just finished checking over my slides and information for the last time. I had to add a lot of information in in a couple places, because I found that there's still a surviving member from the invasion of Normandy - Mr. Arthur Harrington, who was happy to talk with me about his experiences in World War II. We spent about 40 minutes on the telephone this morning, and he gave me some fairly detailed information about what he was up to prior to, during and after the invasion. He was part of the 5th Special Engineering Brigade, and later, the 294 Join Assault Signal Company, supplying communication between the 1st and 29th infantry divisions on the invasion day, June 6th, on Omaha beach. He wasn't aware of any other Norwich people at the invasion, and was interested to learn that several of his classmates were also there, in divisions around him (1st and 29th Infantry). It was a very, very interesting talk, and I'm glad that I caught his name. I'll be sending him a paper once it's finished.
Presentation in 20 minutes. Presentaion Burned to CD, e-mailed to myself and on thumb drive. Let's hope that I don't mess this up.

Alive! And Angry. And Busy

So, still very annoyed about Camp and everything - Furious really, but I have my Normandy Project to distract me for the time being. Couple of recent developments:

- One of the alumni on my list is still alive. And I have a phone number for him. Thus, I am all but bouncing around at this news.

- Finished getting pictures of everyone scanned, and once I isolate the pictures, I'll include them in my presentation tomorrow.

- I'm presenting tomorrow and oh god, I'm not done with my presentation I've got people I still need to include in my paper and gaah.

- Just got the rest of my stuff for the Normandy trip. My flights from NH to London and back is now booked. My hostel in London is booked. Flights to and from London to Paris is now booked. Arrangements to meet people and staying with them have been made. And it's less than a month before the trip.

- Raines, the TV show, is awesome. As is The Zimmers, a band of 90 + year old English people, singing the Who's My Generation, seen here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zqfFrCUrEbY

Apollo 13

So last night, I put in Apollo 13, because I haven't seen it in a very long time. Turns out, that was a bit of a coincidence, because 37 years ago today, a faulty coil caused a spark in the oxygen tanks, causing a small explosion that crippled the ship.
I can't imagine what it must have been like to sit there and watch, how the entire world watched as they returned home. It's a shame there isn't anything like that today to unite the world. Maybe we do need to go back to the moon.

Done! Sort of...

I'm done with my paper! Well, I'm done with the penultimate draft anyway. Topped out at 25 or so pages, without the appendixes (probably 3) and the bibliography. Those will probably add on about five pages or so. I'm not entirely thrilled with the end product, because I don't have all of my research done, and while finishing up, I found a couple of other guys to add to my list, and need to look into their backstories a bit more. Might need to do some more detail work throughout the Normandy campaign, and include some details on the various reunions that Norwich students had in France, which we have quite a bit of details about.
My history class just got back from a trip to Norwich Vermont (Norwich University is located in Northfield, but was originally the American Scientific, Literary and Military acadamy, located at Norwich), which was amusing and interesting, mainly because that class rocks.
In the meantime, I'm going to actually rest for a bit, catch up on my sleep. I just found a cover of Bittersweet Symphony by Coldplay, and I have pizza for dinner. That just about makes up for the foot of snow that fell this morning. And my busted tire that I got on Tuesday night. Blarg.

Typing, typing, typing...

That's about what my day amounted today, and will most likely be tomorrow and the day after. Instead of my paper being due in two weeks, like I'd thought, the next-to-last draft is due this Thursday. Which actually has me less frazzled than I thought it would leave me, because the paper's coming together really well. Current page count is 20 pages, with the first three or so sections done:

  • Introduction / Preperation / Planning for D-Day
  • Day 1: D-Day
  • Days 2-4: D-Day 1-3
  • Days 5-10: D-Day 4-9

The first two sections were really long, the last two were shorter, mainly because there was only one Norwich alum landing each day. The next section, starting with June 11th, will be longer, because not only was there two large units, the 2nd Armored Division and the 39th Infantry arriving, they've got almost ten people between the two of them from Norwich, some of those guys who were fairly important (General Brooks and Col. Flint), but I also have found a lot of information on them.
Still trying to find information on some of the other units, like the 18th Field Artillery, which doesn't seem to exist at times, among others, and I've also uncovered a couple of other alumni who are in the Norwich Record, but somehow didn't make it onto my list, bringing my count up to 28 confirmed alumni, 34 possible. It's quite a number of people. Three sections to do, mainly with the remaining days, a look at what happened after the invasion and the buildup in Normandy occured and the breakout, a mention that there's some more people (like Phil Brackett, an army dentist), who was awarded the Normandy ribbon, but I can't figure out when he was at Normandy. Same goes for a doctor and a couple of people who the Record says was at Normandy, but because I don't know their units, I can't figure out when or what they were doing.
With my files, map-that-doesn't-exist-yet and source list, I think this is going to be somewhere in the 30-40 page ballpark. If people are interested, I'll serialize it once it's finalized, and stick it up here.

Overseas Again...

I learned this the other day, and didn't want to say anything until I was sure, but the big news of the week is:

I'm going overseas again, this time to France, and most likely, London.

Basically, a spot opened up on the Normandy trip here at Norwich, and I got the e-mail earlier this week, and was told by President Schnider that I could go with them, cost free, save the flight over there. This is because I'm working on the Norwich Students & Invasion of Normandy paper that will be giving them a lot of information and putting a Norwich face on the battle. Thus, the invite.
I'm rather excited about this, as it's only about 40 or so days away, about a week after graduation.

What's also really got me excited is that this means that there's a very, very good chance that I'll be able to visit London for a couple days. I looked up flights from New York to Paris, and found them to be fairly prohibitive, running into the thousands of dollars. New York to London, on the other hand, is much cheaper, about half of that, along with the flight or train ride from London to Paris. The chance to see London again is fantastic, because I know people there, and will be able to revisit places again, a year after I left, also, when it will be really nice out. Basically, I've been bouncing around since I've heard the news. What's also cool is that when I went up to tell Mom about my thoughts about travelling through London and how it's cheaper, she suggested it to me first.

Don't get me wrong, going to France and to the Normandy beaches also has me very, very excited, because it was one of those places that I had really wanted to visit while I was overseas last time, but never got the oppertunity to really do. Plus, you know, I've been studying D-Day for the entire semester and did a lot of reading beforehand, and to actually see it would be amazing. I guess this means that my paper has to be really good. I'll be starting my writing on the second part either this afternoon or tomorrow. It's two weeks before the last draft is due, which means that I have three more sections to do, and to do fast. I think I'm on top of it though. If people are interested, I'll reprint it here, serialized, once it's finished.

I can't wait.

Colby Symposium - Day 2

I was up at 7 again this morning to volunteer for the second and final day of the Colby Military Writer's Symposium. This was the big day - the panel discussion that the conference is centered around, and this year's theme, as I mentioned yesterday, Civilians in the Path of War.
However, earlier, there were two other events, one at 8 am, which was a breakfast presentation in Milano Ballroom. It featured John Nagl and Anne Nivat and was focused on journalism in combat zones, from Chechnya to Iraq and Afghanistan. Nagl is a Lt. Colonel in the US Army, and Nivat is a freelance journalist who's been to a number of combat zones, and both talked about the need to tell the public what is going on in places, as well as it's important to get a full story from every side.
I did some driving after that, shuttling authors from place to place by golf cart, which was fun, Gerhard L. Weinberg in the morning, and Mark Grimsley and Clifford J. Rogers later in the afternoon, after Roger's talk about soldiers in the Middle Ages, which proved to be an utterly facinating talk on the changing mentality of soldiers as war has evolved. He was a highly animated and interesting speaker, and I really want to pick up his book on the middle ages at some point.
At 2, there was the main panel, Civilians in the Path of War, and a number of topics were discussed, from the fire bombings of Japan by the American forces, to POW casualties as a result of that, civilians in current conflicts, and the big question asked was: Is it okay to target civilians who collaborate with enemy forces, and what, if there is one, is the line between combatant/insurgent/terrorist? It's a troubling topic, and I don't think that there's any clear answer, and there really wasn't one given. The power went out twice on us, which was problematic, because they were doing a live broadcast. I left after the second outage, because I wasn't all that interested in the student questions. Besides, I had a student to tutor.
Later in the evening, I dressed in better clothes and went to the Meet the Authors Dinner, a formal event in which people with good GPAs, important ranks, or volunteers for the conference were invited, along with teachers, guests and of course, the authors. Mark Grimsley was at my table, and we talked about England and Europe, and the effect of the internet (paticularly blogging, wikipedia and Youtube on mass media these days), which was interesting. A lot of my friends were there, which was fun, to chat with various people about things. Plus, there was an open bar.
Two books were awarded the Colby Award for excellence in military writing. I believe that the only criteria is that they have to be military related writing, political or something similar, and an author's first work in the field. The two books were Conduct Under Fire: Four American Doctors and Their Fight for Life as Prisoners of the Japanese, 1941-1945 by John A. Glusman and Six Frigates: The Epic History of the Founding of the American Navy by Ian W. Toll. Both books look absolutely facinating, and I'm adding Six Frigates to my 'To Buy At Some Point When I Have Income List'. I have one of the previous winners, Franklin and Winston, by Jon Meacham, which won two years ago - the books that they pick for the award are outstanding.



I didn't get a chance to talk with either author to any extent, although I was in a converstation with Mr. Toll earlier today with a couple of other people - interesting guy. The dinner was outstanding, with really good food - Sodexo's chefs read each of the books and tailor meals based on the countries that they're based out of. I had an Iraqi chicken dish with rice - really good, with Pinot Noir Red Wine - Also really good.

That's it for the conference. I said goodbye to some of the authors I'd met, and headed home. It was an enlightening couple of days, to say the least.